The Ultimate Guide to Big Brother Gifts for Toddlers

Welcoming a new baby into the family is an exciting time, but it can be an adjustment for the older sibling. To help your toddler embrace their new role as a big brother, consider giving them a special gift. Big brother gifts can make your toddler feel loved, appreciated, and involved in the new family dynamic. Here we’ll explore some of the best big brother gifts for toddlers, ranging from personalized keepsakes to fun and educational toys.

Personalized Big Brother T-Shirt

Personalized Big Brother Shirt Pregnancy Announcement Sibling Boys Kids T-Shirt 2T California Blue

A personalized big brother t-shirt is a wonderful way to make your toddler feel proud of their new role. You can have their name and the words “Big Brother” printed on the shirt. This gift not only makes them feel special but also helps announce their new status to friends and family.


Big Brother Storybook

Itty Bitty Newborn: 0-3 Months (Big Brother Learns All About Babies)

A big brother storybook is a great way to help your toddler understand their new role and what to expect when the new baby arrives. Look for a book that is age-appropriate and features colorful illustrations and a positive message about being a big brother.


Matching Sibling Outfits

Tstars Big Brother Sister Shirt Little Sis Bro Outfit Sibling Matching Outfits Set Gray 2T / Baby Gray NB (0-3M)

Another cute gift idea is to buy matching outfits for your toddler and the new baby. This can be a fun way for them to bond and feel connected to their younger sibling. You can find a wide variety of matching outfits, from onesies and t-shirts to pajamas and dresses on Amazon and Etsy.


Baby Doll

Manhattan Toy Baby Stella Boy Soft First Baby Doll for Ages 1 Year and Up, 15"

Here’s a great idea! A baby doll is a classic big brother gift for toddlers that can help your child learn about caregiving and responsibility. Encourage your toddler to care for their baby doll, just like you care for the new baby. This can be a great way to prepare them for their new role as a big brother.


Big Brother Activity Kit

I am a Big Brother Activity and Coloring Book: Gift Book that Explores the Role of an Older Sibling and the Excitement of a New Baby through Fun Dinosaur Activities

Consider putting together a big brother activity kit filled with age-appropriate games, puzzles, coloring books, and craft supplies. This can keep your toddler entertained and engaged while you tend to the new baby. It’s also an excellent way to spend quality time with your older child.


Personalized Keepsake

The Paisley Box Personalized Photo Frame/Create Your Own Personalized Picture Frame: Engraved Custom Picture Frame, Customizable Frame (4x6 Inch Vertical Frame)

A personalized keepsake, such as a picture frame, blanket, or ornament, can serve as a lasting reminder of this special time in your toddler’s life. Add their name, birthdate, and a sweet message to create a cherished memento.


Big Brother Certificate

Superhero Sibling Inspirational Cape And Mask Set Great For Those Little Role Models Expecting A Sibling (Brother)

The perfect big brother gift for toddlers is to create a “Big Brother Certificate” to officially welcome your toddler into their new role. You can find templates online or make one yourself, and then frame it as a keepsake. This certificate can make your toddler feel proud and important.


Board Games

Peaceable Kingdom Monkey Around First Game for Toddlers Interactive Play with Parent Ages 2+

Board games are a fantastic way to promote family bonding and help your toddler adjust to their new sibling. Choose age-appropriate games that the whole family can enjoy together. This encourages cooperation and fosters a sense of togetherness.


Personalized Puzzle

ATOOZ Custom Photo Puzzles Custom Puzzle 120 Pieces,Personalized Puzzle with Picture Custom Wooden Puzzle from Photos Wedding, Graduation Ceremony, Halloween

Personalized puzzles featuring your toddler’s favorite photo, cartoon, or artwork can provide hours of entertainment and help improve their problem-solving skills. Plus, they make for a thoughtful and personalized gift for others.


Becoming an older sibling can be an important and meaningful experience for a child for a number of reasons. Some of the benefits of being an older sibling include:

  • Learning responsibility: Being an older sibling often involves helping to care for and look after a younger sibling. This can be a great way for a child to learn about responsibility and develop important life skills.
  • Developing social skills: Older siblings often play an important role in teaching and modeling social skills for younger siblings. This can help an older child learn to communicate effectively and build positive relationships with others.
  • Building self-esteem: Being an older sibling can be a source of pride and accomplishment for a child. It can give them a sense of importance and responsibility within their family, which can boost their self-esteem.
  • Providing a sense of belonging: Being part of a family can be an important source of identity and belonging for a child. Being an older sibling can help a child feel more connected to their family and give them a sense of purpose.

Of course, being an older sibling also comes with challenges, and it’s important for parents to be supportive and understanding as their child adjusts to this new role.

Welcoming a new baby is a significant milestone for your family, and helping your toddler adjust to their role as a big brother is essential. These thoughtful and age-appropriate big brother gifts for toddlers can make your older child feel loved, valued, and excited about their new sibling. Whether it’s a personalized t-shirt, a baby doll, or a big brother certificate, these gifts are sure to bring a smile to your toddler’s face and help them embrace their important role in the family.


GiftGreater is supported by our readers. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. When you buy through any of the links on our site, we may earn a commission. LEARN MORE